Fred Smith's vision myth: debunked for schools.

Fred Smith's vision myth: debunked for schools.

At a glance

Question: How much of your school’s vision should come from the leader, and how much from the community?

Central idea: Leaders can give a vision direction and clarity. The people who will live it can show where it needs to change.

Archive context: From the 2025 newsletter archive.

Fred Smith, founder of FedEx, once put it this way:

People who supposedly have vision, he said, “spend a lot of time reading and gathering information” and then put what they learn together until they come up with an idea.

We should admire what Smith started just over fifty years ago. He died in June 2025, aged 80.

Smith’s account puts the emphasis on the person doing the reading and thinking.

For educational leaders, that raises a crucial question: Is vision something leaders craft independently, or something communities create collaboratively?

In our work across diverse contexts - from Finland to Colombia, Australia to the UAE - we consistently encounter leaders wrestling with exactly this tension.

One camp has a clear vision, eager for help crossing the implementation gap.

The other values deep listening and synthesis, committed to developing strategies, and a vision, born from community input.

Reading and synthesis can help a leader arrive at a big idea. That still leaves the question of whose experience shapes it.

But schools aren’t companies, and our communities are not merely 'customers'.

Schools don't simply have 'consumers'; we have participants who contribute daily, actively shaping the collective experience. Viewing parents, students, and staff as 'customers' inevitably makes the relationship transactional: “What can the school do for me?” replaces “What can we achieve together?”

Yet, vision isn't either-or. It thrives in the interplay between personal clarity and collective insight. A vision forged in isolation risks becoming a beautiful idea nobody else owns; a vision entirely crowdsourced can dilute clarity and purpose.

Real leadership lies in navigating that tension thoughtfully, maintaining clarity of purpose while authentically engaging the community.

So how might you find your sweet spot between personal clarity and community collaboration?

Try this with your team

Draft one sentence about where you want your school to go. Ask students, staff and families what it would change for them and what they would challenge.

Next: Through the Dip: How Strategy Survives Contact with Reality

Colleagues working together on a plan: Pexels.

In categories:

< See all Insights

Some other articles of interest:

Thinking, Learning and Creativity

Thinking, Learning and Creativity

Find Out More >
Don’t Waste “Tired You”

Don’t Waste “Tired You”

Make decisions about rest and routines while you have energy to think them through.

Find Out More >
I interrupted myself. Do you do the same?

I interrupted myself. Do you do the same?

Notice what happens when you interrupt your own focus.

Find Out More >