Through the Dip: How Strategy Survives Contact with Reality

Through the Dip: How Strategy Survives Contact with Reality

At a glance

Question: What should you do when an idea loses its early momentum?

Central idea: Keep the purpose clear and use small tests to see whether an idea needs more work, a different approach or a decision to stop.

Every great idea has a honeymoon phase. The spark, the rush, the moment you can see it coming to life.

And then it dips.

The dip is that uncomfortable, inevitable stage where the shine wears off.

Obstacles arrive.
Feedback bites.
People get busy.
Time runs short.
Budget runs dry.
Emotions run high.

You start to wonder if the idea was really that good after all.

Most people take the dip as a sign to stop: to ditch the idea and chase a fresher, easier one.

They’re wrong. The dip is the work.

The teams we see succeeding in strategy or school transformation are not the ones with perfect plans. They’re the ones with clarity on the end-game, who push into the dip. They adapt, test, adjust, and keep showing up until the idea has grown enough roots to survive.

Prototyping often gets misrepresented as “failing fast” or “killing your darlings”. Ditch an idea at the first sniff of a despondent shrug of feedback.

But really, prototyping is about perseverance. It’s a way of trying small moves, gathering insights, and finding the breakthrough. The first feedback isn’t a verdict. It’s an invitation to keep working.

In schools, this is where strategy lives or dies; not in the writing, but in the living.

Too often, busy work gets in the way, and focus slips.

Or a muddled brand leads to too many competing voices with their own idea of what will fit in the school’s culture. Those misaligned voices crowd out focus, they crowd out novelty, and they kill momentum.

Most ideas will mature and flourish if you and your community can persevere through the dip, holding onto a clarity of purpose, staying curious, resisting the urge to abandon ship.

Others will naturally fall away. And you’ll know the difference because you stayed long enough to see it.

So, the next time you find yourself in the dip, don’t panic. Don’t give up. Work into the idea. It’s the only way it becomes real.

Try this with your team

Name one idea that has hit a dip. Agree on the smallest next test, what you need to learn from it and when you will decide whether to continue.

Next: 101 days left.

A winding trail through rocky hills: Pexels.

In categories:

< See all Insights

Some other articles of interest:

Thinking, Learning and Creativity

Thinking, Learning and Creativity

Find Out More >
Don’t Waste “Tired You”

Don’t Waste “Tired You”

Make decisions about rest and routines while you have energy to think them through.

Find Out More >
I interrupted myself. Do you do the same?

I interrupted myself. Do you do the same?

Notice what happens when you interrupt your own focus.

Find Out More >