Four reasons school strategy decisions get stuck, and what to clarify before your team chooses.

The decisions to make before you make decisions

Four reasons school strategy decisions get stuck, and what to clarify before your team chooses.

The decisions to make before you make decisions

One of the greatest challenges in creating any strategy is answering a simple question: What is it you actually want to achieve? What do you want for our school?

Let's think about something easier. Jam. You might already have explored those lessons from the world of jam, showing how too much choice isn’t always a good thing.

If you go to the supermarket and call around the family asking what everyone wants, you'll probably get four kinds of answer.

  • Someone says, "I want raspberry jam, preferably without the seeds." Great. We've got some criteria. We can ignore most of the jams on the shelf.
  • Someone else says, "I want the best one." Now you need to decide what best means. Best taste? Best ingredients? Cheapest? Something unusual? You need to know the person to know what they mean by best.
  • Someone else says, "Choose something everyone at breakfast will like." Now you're weighing up everyone's different preferences.
  • And finally, someone's shouting, "Just choose! People are waiting. We need to get going." The same display of jams suddenly becomes a very different decision depending on what people want, and the time pressure they're under.

Now take those challenges into a project as complex as designing a brand new school. The consequences are more significant than choosing the wrong jam. You could create the wrong space for the next 50, 75 or 100 years.

Architectural rendering of students in a landscaped school campus courtyard

The equivalent of raspberry jam without seeds becomes: "We need science labs where a whole class can carry out practical work safely." We've been given the criteria, so we might ignore other potentially innovative ways of designing science learning.

"I want the best jam" becomes "We want world-class facilities." This is a brief I've seen in plenty of schools, but what is ‘world-class’? The most expensive? The most innovative? The best value? Something unusual that may or may not work in practice?

"Something everyone at breakfast will like" becomes "We need a masterplan the Board, teachers, students and parents can all get behind." Lots of competing preferences, and the danger of ending up with a compromise that doesn't quite work for anyone.

And "Just choose!" becomes "We need the masterplan approved this semester so construction can start over the summer." That urgency was created because the Board have kicked the decision the road too many times already.

So what makes it so hard to know what you want?

Researcher Alexander Chernev and his colleagues identified four factors that explain why choices become overwhelming.

1. The complexity of the options available.

When the alternatives involve awkward comparisons and trade-offs, there's no obvious winner. In a school, we're often choosing between several genuinely good ideas, all with different benefits. The challenge is finding a design choice that makes the most of those possibilities rather than compromising them away.

2. The difficulty of the decision itself.

There are lots of things to consider, often time pressure, and usually someone who'll want you to justify the decision afterwards.

That's why, when we create strategic plans, we do the hard thinking early. We explore all the options behind the systems we need to build, the capabilities we already have, and the big idea (maybe two) that could take the school somewhere different.

We research the possibilities, debate what's feasible alongside what we dream of achieving, then distil all that thinking into one decision everyone can understand.

3. Uncertainty about your preferences.

If you don’t really know the very few things that your school is committed to, every decision becomes huge. Some of the best schools in the world are great for very different reasons, but each one is known for just one thing. Gordonstoun has pursued expeditionary learning. Geelong Grammar School has made positive education central to its approach. School 21 in London has developed a distinctive model of learning around oracy and real-world experiences. These schools have a clear sense of what they want to achieve. That makes the hundreds of smaller decisions much easier, because there's something to align them to.

4. Not knowing the goal behind the decision.

Sometimes we just want to get the decision made with minimal effort and minimal time, rather than explore what all the options might be.

I see this particularly in school communications, admissions and brand strategy. Every new message becomes another discussion. Is this the right thing to say? Is this the right time? Who should communicate it?

If you've not worked out your goal, you have to explore these questions every single time.

It's one reason our Brand Strategy for Schools work goes well beyond logos and websites. We help schools define what they actually stand for, craft that into a story people understand, and make it something everyone can use in their daily work. Admissions, communications and faculty can make decisions with confidence because they've already worked out what they're trying to achieve together.

Here's something to try this week.

Take one significant decision your leadership team is struggling to make.

Ask yourselves which of Chernev's four factors is making it difficult:

  • Are the options too complex?
  • Is the decision itself too demanding?
  • Are you unsure what you really prefer?
  • Or have you not agreed on what you're trying to achieve?

The answer might tell you where to concentrate your effort before your next meeting. Remember: the hardest part of making a decision is working out what you actually want in the first place.

In category:

< See all Insights

Some other articles of interest:

Building a Strong School Culture

Building a Strong School Culture

A collection by NoTosh on the everyday choices, relationships and routines that shape how a school feels and works.

Find Out More >
Don’t trust your vision. Trust your habits.

Don’t trust your vision. Trust your habits.

Make useful habits easy to repeat when attention moves elsewhere.

Find Out More >
The ROI of a Tablecloth

The ROI of a Tablecloth

Look for the small choices that show people their work matters.

Find Out More >